If you’re facing criminal charges and wondering whether you should make a statement to the police, our short answer is an emphatic “No!” There are countless people in prison and jail because they made an incriminating statement to a law enforcement officer. Police aren’t necessarily interested in safeguarding your rights; their only concern is closing the case. You can’t get out of trouble by making a statement, but you can dig yourself even deeper. Below, you will learn the four reasons you shouldn’t give a statement to the police.
1. The hearsay rule: Evidentiary rules guarantee that you can only harm your case by speaking to law enforcement. If you plead your innocence, your statement is considered hearsay, and cannot be used in court. However, there is one exception: admission by party opponent. Under this rule, if you say something that demonstrates your guilt, it can be used against you.
2. Talking to the prosecution’s attorneys: Police do not have the authority to offer you a better deal; the prosecutorial team makes sentencing recommendations. Anything you say to law enforcement will be more beneficial if you say it to the attorney prosecuting your case.
3. Risk of contradicting yourself: Even an innocent person can contradict himself or herself if under stress. During a police interrogation, everything you say is being recorded; each time you tell your story, there is a chance of an inconsistency. Prosecutors use these inconsistencies during a trial to demonstrate that you are hiding things.
4. Risking a false confession: Good interrogation has a scientific component, and most police officers are proficient. Some law enforcement officers want a confession, even if you did not commit the crime; many who have later been exonerated by DNA proof were convicted because of a false confession. You can avoid the manipulation by not making a statement to police, and by hiring a
5. Lawyer Easton
6. Ask to Talk to an Attorney
Even if you are confident that you can clear the charges against you, you should not talk to law enforcement without first consulting a Lawyer Easton. Police will try to use your words against you, and to cast doubt on your version of the facts. It’s best to speak to a criminal defense lawyer before making a statement.